I've got a job where I regularly travel 55,000 to 60,000 miles a year. My current pickup is a Ford F150(long story). Because of how much I travel, I'd like to find something that will last a few years and be fairly economical. I was set on the 6 cylinder Duramax because of the fuel economy, but with diesel prices so ridiculous, I'm now considering the 2.7l turbo 4 cylinder. Has anyone looked at a detailed comparison between those 2 engines? Longevity, fuel economy, and upkeep?
They haven't been out very long but both seem to be fantastic choices.
The 4 cylinder is going to be cheaper on the upkeep most likely. Fuel economy the diesel takes it but is most likely a wash since it is more expensive.
Plus you have to spend $2K+ every 150K on the Duramax to replace the oil pump belt if you want to keep it running. With your miles that would happen every three years, so maybe you'll trade it in before that.
I don't have any experience with the baby duramax, but the only thing that kept me away from it was the rising prices in late 2021. I went with the 2.7 L3B. I haven't had any problems with the motor. I usually receive about 19-21MPG, also counting that it is leveled and on Falken AT3Ws.
The only thing I've done is oil changes with a tire rotation. I purchased mine with 18K miles now it's at 41k. Longeivity is unsure as it's a new setup for GM but if I can get about 150k miles I'll be satisifed.
Overall, people sleep on it as they prefer the big V8s and I totally agree they are badass, but when the GM trucks have to get bundled with other packages to step into a V8, is where I said no thanks.
Can't beat the 4 banger for the money. Diesel is nice if you have the extra $$$. Pulling a trailer with the 2.7 turbo is pretty impressive, nice on gas when traveling too!
I was just looking at a 2023 GMC Sierra Elevation "In Transit" to a local dealer and the 3.0L engine is $2390 extra.
An Elevation with a 2.7L TURBO HIGH-OUTPUT ENGINE -1,500.00 CREDIT
So the 3.0L will cost you more money, $3890 in my example. ? is the slight increase in fuel economy but increased maintenance worth the added expense of Higher fuel prices, def fluid, special oil, fuel filters etc.
Thanks for all the input. This is helpful. I realize the price discrepancy between diesel and gas fluctuates over time, but I don't see it getting any better in the near future. My bigger concern is maintenance and other long term concerns. Although it seems GM is putting that 2.7 in everything, so maybe there's a reason they seem so confident in it.
The 2.7 hasn't been around long enough for me to trust that it's sliding camshafts are going to hold up long term... Not to mention that the typical life cycle of a diesel is always greater than a gas engine. So, if you are planning on putting 3-400,000 miles on this truck, I would think the diesel would get you there. I don't know that the gasser would...
This used to be a foregone conclusion, but not so much anymore, IME. While the engine components are still built to diesel specs (which should lend itself to long-term reliability), all of the required EPA systems are the (expensive) Achilles heel. DEF injectors, heaters, pumps, sensors, particle filters, and numerous other parts can get expensive quickly once you're out of warranty. I've owned many diesels in my day and simply avoid them now. My view would be different if I were towing 50%+ of the time
As mentioned, the 2.7 doesn't have a crazy long track record yet, but it's not exactly new. When compared to a lot of recently-launched engines, it seems to be well on the more-reliable side. I'm a new 2.7 owner so I can't provide personal long-term ownership experience yet. I only drive ~30K miles per year. I find the driving dynamics of the 2.7 very similar to small diesels I've driven over the years, which is one of the main reasons I chose it.
My 22 Custom only has about 600 miles on it but I’m seeing at best 18.5 mpg with an equal mix of town and interstate and I don’t drive it like I stole it either. I am hoping the little 2.7 does better after it gets more miles on it.
The interior is amazing! I will say some of the exterior design cues are a little questionable, but it depends on your taste. I definitely don't know if I owned a GMC truck again, I'd prob look at other competitors first. Lol
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Related Threads
?
?
?
?
?
Chevy Silverado and GMC Sierra Forum
1.4M posts
180.1K members
Since 2009
A forum community dedicated to Chevrolet Silverado and GMC Sierra pickup owners and enthusiasts. Come join the discussion about performance, modifications, classifieds, troubleshooting, maintenance, and more!