Chevy Silverado and GMC Sierra Forum banner

Which tire would you choose and why?

  • BFG K03, C-rated. 56 lbs

    Votes: 6 43%
  • Nitto Terra Grappler G3, E-rated. 55 lbs

    Votes: 4 29%
  • Nitto Terra Grappler G3, SL-rated. 48 lbs

    Votes: 0 0%
  • Falken Wildpeak AT4W, SL-rated. 53 lbs

    Votes: 4 29%

Need tires, help me choose: BFG, Falken, Nitto

239 views 34 replies 13 participants last post by  Hi-Country  
#1 ·
Time to replace my KM3s. There’s not much offroading in my immediate future, so moving away from an MT and looking at ATs so I can get better street manners. I’m sure I’ll regret this decision the minute I get stuck in mud or wet grass…

I can’t recall the last time I bought an AT for my daily driver. I recently put Yoko G015s on my wife’s Suburban, but it’s really just a street tire…I‘m looking for something a bit more rugged.

Size I’m looking at is 285/70-17.
Have narrowed it down to the tires in the poll, but happy to look at others.

Leaning toward the SL-rated Nittos, but I’m concerned about puncture resistance. The K03 looks good, but a C-rated BFG weighs the same as an E-rated Nitto. The Falken is just heavy for a P-metric SL tire.

What would you guys recommend, and why?
 
  • Like
Reactions: swathdiver
#2 ·
I buy American, so KO3s. Hopefully, they are not road hazard magnets like my KO2s were. 3 tires patched after four years.

Michelin Defenders have taken me just about everywhere the KO2s went without issue. No punctures after four years.
 
  • Like
Reactions: pronstar
#4 · (Edited)
I've run both the Falken line and currently operating with Nitto Grapplers G2's on my '01 SWB 4 x 4 and wearing very well...I will more than likely run Nitto G3's in the future.
 
  • Like
Reactions: pronstar
#5 ·
I did not like my AT4w's nearly as much as I did my AT3w's. They were noticeably noisier, way heavier, and it took replacing 2 during initial install to get 4 decent road force measurements. Might have been a one off, but, have also seen anecdotal reports of that being more widespread in the 4th gen. They do look damned good though.

THe k03 intrigues me a lot. As did the k02 before it. Have not run a set personally.

Im REALLY pleasantly surprised by the GY Territory MTs on my ZR2. First and foremost, the GM version is mega cheap (like $150/$200 cheaper per tire comparative to other name brands.) I haven't really challenged them at all yet, but their road manner are shockingly nice. I assume they are as good as a duratrac or so, in the slop.

If nitto made the g3 in my size, I would already be running them haha. They seem to really blend the best of all words, paired with care/quality. They always balance out well, have low road force, and last a good while. I think my only option with them at the moment is the trail graps for OE sizing. Though I too intend to replace with some form of gentler AT. If both E and SL are avail, id go E personally.

Special mention to the baja boss at. ive heard really great things @GOAT721 im pretty sure runs them. No personal experience. They look sooo good, but they also look noisy. Goat says differently though I think, Im pretty sure he reported them to be very comfortable.
 
#16 ·
I read somethjng similar about the Falkens..they do look good LOL

I got a smoking deal on my current 33x12.5-17 KM3s,paid $750 shipped from a distributor buddy. That deal is long gone LOL… but bad UCA bushings caused some cupping to one tire and it’s loud as hell…that’s totally on me. I should have noticed the bushings were shot sooner.
 
#15 ·
Which one?
I used to run Toyo mats on my diesel and they were seemingly the default choice back in the 2010s for an HD truck.

Interesting no one is voting for the P-metric/SL rated tire. They’re about $75/tire less…

As of now I‘m leaning toward the BFG or E-rated Nitto. Im traveling for work a bit over the next few weeks so plenty of time to mind-eff this decision LOL
 
  • Like
Reactions: PaleRider
#17 ·
Alignment along with tight ball joints, CV joints, tie-rod ends...etc. Always before a new set of shoes. (y)
 
#20 ·
OK so these are tempting simply due to price…IIRC this was one of the tires Toyota put in the previous-gen 4Runners from the factory.

Image
 
#26 ·
OK so these are tempting simply due to price…IIRC this was one of the tires Toyota put in the previous-gen 4Runners from the factory.

View attachment 996839
The 3s were good tires. Some people have complained about the 4s being hard to balance or not taking a balance/out of round. But they’re mass produced tires, you’re gonna find a few bad ones everywhere.
 
#21 ·
Honestly the Toyo Open Country AT3 was my go to tire for a while. But I traded mine off to go Michelin. Once they got about half worn the wet traction went to absolute garbage. Even at about 75% worn these Michelins do better.

However, since the suburban has taken over daily driver and family hauler duty almost exclusively, I’m debating going back to a more “fun” and good looking tire. Been eyeing up the newer falken at4.
 
#22 ·
I wanted to get the new KO3's to replace the Toyo Open Country MT's 35's that came with my current rig. My last rig had the old KO2's which served me well. However, the KO3's didn't come in 37's (I wanted to go with 37's instead of 35's) at the time and since I needed tires immediately, I went with Toyo Open Country AT3's. The KO3's came out a couple of months later:rolleyes:. So far they're doing very well. Definitely a smoother ride on the highway than the Open Country MT's and the old KO2's. As I just got them back in May, I can't provide any long-term comments. By the time I can, Toyo will probably have Open Country AT4's!
 
owns 2015 GMC Sierra 2500HD Denali
#25 ·
I’ve got them in my cart, want someone to talk me out of them LOL
 
#27 ·
So the brand snob within me thinks I’m gonna regret this, but I just ordered the Coopers.
5 tires for $1100, and I’ll be rotating my spare into service.

Honestly my wallet needed some relief, we recently had $45k in medical expenses for my oldest son (he’s 4.5 years old) and insurance didn’t cover any of it.
 
#29 ·
So the brand snob within me thinks I’m gonna regret this, but I just ordered the Coopers.
5 tires for $1100, and I’ll be rotating my spare into service.

Honestly my wallet needed some relief, we recently had $45k in medical expenses for my oldest son (he’s 4.5 years old) and insurance didn’t cover any of it.
Cooper is a good tire. Ran (2) sets on a '05 Dodge hemi 4 x 4 truck. Keeping a 6k mile rotation interval they lasted as advertised. No off-roading.
 
  • Like
Reactions: pronstar
#33 · (Edited)
Toyo Open Country all the way.. I’ve tried all the rest.. Wranglers at’s were junk, Noisy and rough on my daughter's Trail Boss, Stock Hankook wow so noisy on my 2500. Unimpressed with Grappler’s on my last 2500. My daughter had Toyos on her 06 1500 a while back and I loved how smooth and quiet they were with decent snow going capability
 
#34 ·
Bridgestone - DUELER A/T ASCENT load range E for my 2500. I had 2 sets of BFGs T/A KO2s and had to switch when they stopped making them. Original tires when new were GY Wrangler DURATRACs. DURATRACs were fine when new, after 25K miles and regular rotations, they wore unevenly and became unbearably noisy. The Bridgestone Ascents were highest rated for winter conditions of all the A/Ts tested so that decided it for me.

See: https://www.tirerack.com/tires/test...y.jsp?ttid=337&srsltid=AfmBOooIfDjtwzu-x73oxD6l4nfnY0jvJqQMVuBoMtM4aNs4o69hfiAy

AND

 
#35 ·
How many flavors of Ice Cream does Baskin-Robbins have...(31) I believe...we're getting close.